My endo continues to encourage me to leave my Dexcom G7 behind and try out the newest version of the Medtronic cgm closed loop system. I had heard that the Medtronic cgm was awful. Has anyone tried this yet? I really need to hear some feedback.
1 Like
Hi @daisymae ! It’s been a while, I hope things are going well for you. I have not tried the Medtronic although I spoke with an acquaintance a few months ago who reported it as “fantastic” but has never used anything else but Medtronic so might not be a reliable source. The tubes are a non starter for me, whatever I do has to be tubeless. I personally am sticking with Dexcom and Omnipod for the foreseeable future.
2 Likes
Have you tested out the libre 3 plus??
I don’t know if it’s released yet but eventually the Medtronic pump will have the option to work with the Libre3 plus.
I think will be a Libre that’s labeled/packaged specifically for Medtronic pumps. I don’t believe users can go out and buy a normal Libre 3 plus and plug it in to the system. Not totally sure so hope this isn’t bad info.
3 Likes
I’ve seen some people say the new Medtronic setup is pretty promising, especially with that closed loop design, though others still swear by Dexcom G7 for its ease of use
2 Likes
I have a friend who is on a POD and Dexcom closed loop system and swears that it had been life altering in her D care and her entire life. She still uses the G6 despite my telling her about the ease of the G7, etc. I often woneder how people make these little decisions for themselves…for example, shes all modern and on the closed loop but still wont switch over to the G7? Ah, well…
2 Likes
Nice to hear from you daisymae. I was trained as an economist, and the field is populated by lots of people who wonder the same thing - and have argued about it for centuries.
W/r/t diabetes care there are so many quantifiable factors, but that just gives one more to wonder about, as you note.
I also have not made the switch from the G6 to the G7, and so you’d be puzzled w/ me as well. My reasons: initially there was a lot of disappointment because of sensor failures and i’m in a habit with the G6 - it doesn’t seem worth it to switch.
I’m sure I will be forced to switch within the year, and i will probably be as happy with the G7 as with the G6 (which is 7 or 8 on a 10 pt scale). I’m a little lazy though.
2 Likes
I was on the Medtronic with guardian CGS. This was 10+ years ago. My doctor recommended the TandemTSlim along with the Dexcom G6(5?). It was so much more accurate than the Medtronic Guardian. Maybe ithe Guardisn has improved but the Dexcom is very accurate . I have not switched to the G 7 yet
3 Likes
I am waiting for my warrenty to expire and then i am switching from the Medtronic to the TandemSlim with my Dexcom G7. (I LOVE it! and such an improvefment from the G4, G5 and G6) My Endo has been encouraging me to consider the newest edition of the Guardian claiming that it is MUCH more accurate that models past. He is a T1D wearing a Medtronic himself and test drives all the different equiptment out their on himself. Interesting guy. Currently he is testing out both the Guardian and the Dexcom on the same arm and he claims that he is finding excellent accuracy from the Guardian. Who knows.`
6 Likes
Very cool to hear he is trying them and not based on a company sales pitch.
4 Likes