The benefit of having a government negotiate drug prices is that it eliminates the need for PBMs entirely and also nearly eliminates the cost of drug companies negotiating with insurance companies. Also, laws against advertising lowers those costs too.
If everyone negotiated individually with drug companies, costs would skyrocket
Guys, this thread is getting a bit too heated up, let’s give it a rest! We all know that each one of us would give his shirt to help another in this community, but political threads still heat up too much and can create animosity.
So let’s close this one. If you disagree, pm me, and, if there are enough requests, we’ll reopen it.
{EDIT] OK, reopened, but please be sure to keep this thread without tension!
The notion of individuals negotiating themselves isn’t really how it would work…
If humalog cost 80% as much as novolog and people were purchasing their own meds, or even paying a direct proportion of the costs themselves, then the demand for humalog would go up and demand for novolog down… across many thousands of people, none of them whom had to negotiate anything themselves. To stay competitive, novolog prices would have to then lower.
Instead we have novolog and humalog both simultaneously and in lock step raising their fake list price, while negotiating a increasingly huge rebate behind the scenes…
Gads. Time to put my foot in my mouth and support @Sam a bit … Seems like he is on his own here 
I’d cancel the cable TV, but I would switch before canceling my internet… maybe even if I had to cancel internet, cell phone, etc.
Me too. And I developed it after 15 years on an insulin pump. So I can’t tie that to NPH/R, which I did relatively well on for the first 1/2 of my life. Exceptionally well, in fact. It was just that I had to follow a specific routine that did not work well for me in the long term. A pump was a better option, but the Humulin/Novolin was awful for me. Everyone’s mileage varies with every treatment.
I do know people who use beef/pork insulins (outside the US), as well as NPH.
In a 2016 market research study by Boston University, they said:
Glargine vs. NPH
All identified studies found no significant differences in HbA1c concentration after treatment
_with glargine compared to NPH. _
Detemir vs. NPH
None of the identified studies showed a significant difference in HbA1c concentration between
detemir and NPH treatment groups.
Meh - it is more like things are priced to the country and ability to pay. We in the US/Canda get to pick up the slack on the cost. I did see a post in another thread about Tresiba in Russia. It was funny to me, as they price it per milliliter, and not per box. I think the ad had 100 rubles per ml (about $15 USD). However, I have priced it there back in September '17 - it would cost me $300 per box. Humulog would cost me about $67 per vial.
But then there far more insulin producing companies in Asia, Eastern Europe, and Latin America versus high income countries (Again, see that Boston U report).
Just my $0.02 +/- worth.
Did you mean to say not awful?
Nope. On the pump, with Humulin/Novolin, my A1C’s went way out of whack and I had complications as a result. Humulog/Novolog didn’t work well either. Apidra was my “savior” on the pump, until I had absorption issues and scarring.
Oh I see I get what you mean… was confused by the wording…
A dudn’t knew wat u ment. I rit gud…
Lol all my posts are from an iPhone, cut me some slack
Hey - I was picking on MY OWN writing. 
I love cable.
Honestly, I think this may be the sticking point for most of us. 
I don’t even have cable, so to me this is just a very bizarre idea… it’s very possible, however, @Sam loves cable way more than most of us can even imagine, meaning he’d be fine with, say, developing neuropathy or retinopathy, etc., as long as he could watch Game of Thrones or whatever else it is that’s currently on TV.
Realistically, there are some people who choose (if not consciously) to worsen their health significantly in order to maintain certain other creature comforts. People who choose to smoke or like my dad, who will continue to eat high salt diet despite it worsening his heart condition, etc…
I probably do love cable more than average joe… but my point was to show that I’d switch to any different insulin and i really don’t expect it to be that horrible or detrimental to my health . We will see. I hope my experiment makes some other people feel more empowered and less dependent on a system that doesn’t value their well-being.
The economic theory on oligopoly pricing (that I read about 40 years ago?) would tend to disagree with your conclusion. If there are only a few “competitors” their prices tend to converge and to rise more or less in lockstep even if they aren’t explicitly colluding.
Yeah, so did beyond type 1… I say anything and people get mad, they say it and it’s a public service
His intent was not to prove that “it’s not that big of a deal.” Perhaps that was the difference…
Sam did you do an experiment and post an update? Did you also use dexcom like the one in the link ?
The true challenge would to do NPH, Reg, without dexcom, and minimal BG tests. Having CGMS makes a big difference, since the action of NPH is less predictable/repeatable with each dose. Person without insurance is not likely to have CGMS.