Hi @john_coburg! It’s nice to meet you.
I’m similar to you in that I’m not a big fan of pumps. I was diagnosed about 25 years ago. Started on NPH and Regular- hated how regimented that made my life. I switched to Humalog and Lantus when those came out then eventually to a pump. I switched off the pump back to Lantus for a couple of years and then tried Tresiba for a year or two before switching back to Lantus.
Tresiba was a really bad fit for me for multiple reasons, but one of those was that I couldn’t easily adjust my basal. I like to go on long hikes, and if I’m going to do sustained activity like that, I need to be able to decrease my basal. I’m also a woman in my 30s and my monthly hormone cycle really impacts my basal needs- I learned to track this pattern from @T1Allison.
Anyway, all that to say that I do think Lantus or Levemir might help you a lot- especially with a cgm. CGMs are just so valuable. I look back now and wonder how I had any level of control before getting a cgm.
I do two Lantus shots a day- one at 9 am and one at 4 pm. I need less insulin in the early morning and more in the evenings. This timing addresses that well. Lantus tends to peak a bit around 6-8 hours after my dose and seems to start wearing off around 18-20 hours. If I have carbs at breakfast, I have to dose aggressively or I’ll go high. I usually keep that meal low carb, and I guess that is my compromise in using Lantus rather than a pump.
I use Afrezza and Humalog as my boius insulins. Afrezza is an inhalable insulin that works really fast. It’s improved my quality of life a lot because it’s easy to get back in range without the same worries about lows. A lot of insurance plans don’t cover it, and I’m not sure if I’ll be able to keep using it next year or not. I got lucky this year.
I target an average bg of 110 and usually have a standard deviation of 25-30. With the pandemic, that has increased to 35. I’m not able to swim like I used to and my overall activity levels are lower. I’m working on that. I do watch my cgm quite a bit during the day and make adjustments as needed. Bg excursions make me exhausted, so I’d rather stay on top of it and feel good. Im sure I’d benefit from a pump loop system, but I hate the thought of having a pump attached to me all the time. I also had a lot of problems with sites, but I probably should’ve tried different infusion sets
With Afrezza, it’s really easy to head off bg excursions before they spiral out of control. If I do go over 160, it’s generally just for a brief amount of time. My understanding is that brief excursions aren’t as bad as sustained excursions. Some studies show that people without diabetes can briefly spike up to 160 after meals before quickly heading back into range. If I remember correctly, Afrezza shaved a good 10 mg/dL off both my average and standard deviation- maybe even more. Not to be a walking advertisement for Afrezza- I often end up doing this I don’t even know if that’s an option where you live.
It sounds like a good first step for you would be to try out Lantus or Levemir with a cgm. The combination could allow for much better control than you experienced with Lantus before. That’s my opinion anyway. Hope some of this rather long post might help.